Skip to main content
On-Demand Meetings
Create Clip
Add To List

From Impact Factor to Impact Framework: Transforming How We Evaluate Research

From Impact Factor to Impact Framework: Transforming How We Evaluate Research
The Journal Impact Factor (JIF) has long dominated research evaluation, shaping funding decisions, institutional rankings, and academic career advancement. However, as the scholarly publishing community pushes for more holistic and responsible research assessment, alternative metrics and incentive structures are gaining traction (e.g., Citescore, Altmetric, DORA initiatives, etc.) This session will explore the current state of models for evaluating research impact, including open science practices, real-world applications, community engagement, and qualitative measures, while addressing the challenges of cultural change in academia and publishing. Panelists from across the scholarly ecosystem will share insights on how publishers, funders, researchers, and institutions can work toward policies that reward diverse contributions to knowledge. The discussion will also highlight case studies of successful transitions toward broader evaluation frameworks.
Publication Date
October 2025

New Directions 2025

7
Thirty years ago, Charlie Munger delivered his now-famous “Psychology of Human Misjudgment” speech at Harvard, where he argued that the behaviors we observe—whether in individuals, organizations, or markets—are the natural result of underlying incentive structures. This theme will delve into how different stakeholders such as researchers, institutions, publishers, funders, and governments create and respond to incentives. From the evolution of open access models to the business strategies behind publishing workflows, we will examine the systemic forces steering the future of scholarly publishing and ask how these incentives align with our values and what we can do to impact the forces that shape the knowledge ecosystem.

Anna Hatch

2

Program Officer, Open Science Strategy, Howard Hughes Medical Institute

Dmytro Filchenko

1

Senior Director, Clarivate

Jamie Devereaux

2

Senior Journals Manager, Medicine & Public Health, Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. Publishers

Jon Gurstelle

3

Senior Director, Publications, American Political Science Association

Marie McVeigh

3

Research Integrity and Publishing Ethics, Elsevier

Meredith Lemasurier

2

SVP, Editorial Development, Taylor and Francis